propglenn

Indie Artist
Indie Artist
I need to preface this post by saying I LOVE Shunkan Sentimental! Hard driving rock just the way I like it. And the video is AWESOME. They really brought out the energy in that one.

So now.....While listening to it I thought I recognized the opening riff. It sounds pretty damn similar to Stereo Pony's Hirohira no Hanabita. The parent company for both bands is Sony so there probably won't be any lawsuit.

Compare them and decide.



Last edited by propglenn on Sun Feb 07, 2010 5:06 pm; edited 1 time in total

Back to top Go down

nekomimi190220

Mainstream Artist
Mainstream Artist
Shunkan still rocks for me XD

Back to top Go down

Plutonium

International Performer
International Performer
Are you sure you spelt the song right?

Or is that another song? o_O

If it's the one I'm thinking of, I'd say Shunkan is better.


_________________________________________________________________________________________________
Back to top Go down

propglenn

Indie Artist
Indie Artist
Sorry Pluto. You're right. It's Hirohira not Hirohita. It's just that opening riff. Search Youtube. But I agree theat Shunkan is better!

Back to top Go down

haruhiyuu

International Performer
International Performer
http://koudai-na-sekai.blogspot.com/
both songs are good but still shunkan wins :D Happy


_________________________________________________________________________________________________

Eki x Tomia x Miyuko ♥


userbar by reo (y)
Back to top Go down

YLenalee

Indie Artist
Indie Artist
It's Hitohira no Hanabira not Hirohira >_<
So I like both, Hitohira no Hanabira the first song of Stereo Pony I heard the first time when I watched Bleach ending thanks to this song I discover this amazing band ^^
But I chose Shunkan Sentimental because it's more rock and also because I can play it with my guitar >_<
I think I have to learn Hitohira no Hanabira too ... UHUH!


_________________________________________________________________________________________________
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]

....
Back to top Go down

Kurotaka

Mainstream Artist
Mainstream Artist
Cry NOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!¨

It's too hard to choose... I really like the two songs...

Sorry guys, but I can't say which song I prefer. ^^


_________________________________________________________________________________________________
Back to top Go down

Karasu

Indie Artist
Indie Artist
Hitohira no Hanabira was my favorite before.. then came Shunkan Sentimental. :soundtrip:


_________________________________________________________________________________________________
Back to top Go down

Kyon

Indie Artist
Indie Artist
I love Stereo pony and both songs are good,
but I choose Shunkan Sentimental.


_________________________________________________________________________________________________
Back to top Go down

asagi132

Shiroten Performer
Shiroten Performer
http://asagi132.wordpress.com/
propglenn wrote:So now.....While listening to it I thought I recognized the opening riff. It sounds pretty damn similar to Stereo Pony's Hirohira no Hanabita..
Hmm, never thought about that...
I think it's pretty different though...

For me, at first I think Shunkan sounds like SCANDAL BABY...
Always got confused between those two songs... Sweating


_________________________________________________________________________________________________
[You must be registered and logged in to see this link.]
Back to top Go down

gunnersforlife

International Performer
International Performer
http://gunners-4life.blogspot.com/
I think the song isn't too similar...
I like both song, but still, i prefer Shunkan..

Back to top Go down

K2Kai

Shiroten Performer
Shiroten Performer
Shunkan Sentimental for sure. The song's stuck in my head and I've been listening to it like at least 10 times a day Hohoho Onion

The PV rocks too. The spark effects :sugoi:

Back to top Go down

Miraclediving

Shiroten Performer
Shiroten Performer
bot song are good, still better shunkan (for me). But stereopony rocks!

Back to top Go down

jac-kira

Caless Student
Caless Student
http://www.phentos.forosactivos.net
both are good but I'll take shunkan

Back to top Go down

brink01

Caless Student
Caless Student
XD
Shunkan is better. Hitohira no Hanabira is different. and I think it's not the same in the intro

Back to top Go down

zenry000

Indie Artist
Indie Artist
^

Shunkan Sentimental Hands Down Yo~ Not saying that Hitohira No Hanabira is bad, but both songs doesn't feel the same Glasses Onion


_________________________________________________________________________________________________
-Working On A New Siggy-
RINA! RINA! ROCK YOU!
Back to top Go down

JpRock

Caless Student
Caless Student
Shunkan Sentimental, No doubt about it

Back to top Go down

LieAnn

International Performer
International Performer
It's different.. The opening riff..

I prefer Shunkan. It's a head-banging song unlike Hitohira (though I like this too but it doesn't give me the "rock song effect" feeling). Just think which song gives you more adrenalin rush.. Hahahaha


_________________________________________________________________________________________________

もっと、もっと、もっと、もっと、もっと声が聞きたいのに
何で、何で、何で、何で届かない
Back to top Go down

~kc~

International Performer
International Performer
Shunkan Sentimental for sure! the first Scandal song that i have listened to.


_________________________________________________________________________________________________


Back to top Go down

lotusnipe

Caless Student
Caless Student
Shunkan Sentimental. It made me addicted to SCANDAL.

Back to top Go down

Paladinoras

Indie Artist
Indie Artist
Both songs are pretty different, so it's hard to make a fair comparison, but personally, I liked Shunkan more. Hitohira no Hanabira is a great song, but after 100 listens or so, I got bored of it, while I still listen to Shunkan after 200ish times.


_________________________________________________________________________________________________


Please, call me Pally. XD
Back to top Go down

Gee

Caless Student
Caless Student
i love both bands, i love both songs... comparing them in this site would just have biased opinions i think...

these two songs have their own taste so i'd say nothing is better than the other... Hitohira is a cool mellow-ish rock song, Shunkan is a heavymetal type.

sorry guys, i can't giva an answer :D

Back to top Go down

Ronrinesu

Indie Artist
Indie Artist
http://www.ai-no-storia.com/
I love both songs but I haven't noticed any similarity between them.


_________________________________________________________________________________________________
You are a drop in the rain,
just a number not a name




And you don't see it
You don't believe



    Blog ♒ DeviantART ♒ Tumblr ♒ MyAnimeList ♒ Last.fm 


    ♒ Ask.fm
Back to top Go down

MDV

Caless Student
Caless Student
The similarity isn't that big. And even if it was and they weren't on the same label it would be very wrong and stupid to start a lawsuit over one or two similar melodies. I don't see the problem as long as they don't copy entire songs without crediting the original composers.

I think I prefer Shunkan Sentimental over Hitohira no Hanabira. Shunkan Sentimental just has more power.


_________________________________________________________________________________________________
No right to feel offended or insulted can be derived from this message.
Back to top Go down

yuizone

Caless Student
Caless Student
for me scandal s song is something like a poison.

and stereopomy s song is something like a hammer.

both song shoot to my heart in different way.

but aimi could kill me with the fisrt melody riff .

faster than the other one .

dont know why .

Back to top Go down