It's not a forum game, it's a discussion (using the format of a forum game hahaha)

How would you list Scandal members in subjective (and some objective) matters like:

- Appearance
1) Mami
2) Rina
3) Tomomi
4) Haruna
Very subjective, obviously. And they are all good looking.

- Voice
1) Mami
2) Haruna
3) Tomomi
4) Rina
Also quite subjective. They all have nice voices, too.

- Humour
1) Tomomi
2) Mami
3) Haruna
4) Rina
Tomomi is very funny.  No arguing there. And I think Mami is the best companion for her in that sense. Haruna and Rina try sometimes, but they are... stiff.

- Maturity
1) Rina
2) Haruna
3) Mami
4) Tomomi
My impression is that when they were younger Haruna was the most centered one. Of course she is still very focused and is respected by the others for being older, but I feel Rina has a strong sense of duty and seems to be very professional, with a great common sense notion. For me the top goes to her on that one. Of course I'm not a long-time fan and may lack some informations other members may know better.

What about you? Feel free to add more parameters!

Beauty
Mami
Tomomi, Haruna, Rina

Voice
Haruna & Tomomi
Mami
Rina

Humour
Tomomi
Tomomi
Tomomi
Tomomi

Maturity
Rina
Haruna
Tomomi
Mami

I'm a 2 months Scandal fan... I don't do miracles hahahaha

You think Mami is the least mature? Why?

Just preconception... I don't know them because my only source is youtube.
She likes the same things that I do... so :D She is a big kid
Hahahaha

Like videogames and anime? But what does that have to do with maturity? Maturity is like being prudent and having common sense.

I didn't say that she is imature.
Be less mature doesn't mean immaturity.
This will be a loop if we further discuss
hahahahaha

It's true, you're right. I'm just very Mami biased. lol

Appearance is a hard one but Tomomi, Mami, Rina then Haruna. Voice I think Rina has the best singing voice then Haruna, Tomomi and Mami. Humour Tomomi easy and I agree Mami compliments her well. I love watching the two of them have fun. Maturity I think maybe Rina. She is Kawaii but seems well centred. But I will finish with, I love Tomomi and Mami 

Listing the members was harder than I thought, 'cause their are all so beautiful and talented.

– Apperance
\1\Mami and Rina
\2\Haruna
\3\Tomomi
\4\ -


– Voice
\1\Haruna
\2\Mami and Rina
\3\Tomomi
\4\ -


– Humour
\1\Tomomi
\2\Mami
\3\Haruna and Rina
\4\ -


– Maturity
\1\Rina
\2\Haruna
\3\Mami
\4\Tomomi

– Apperance
1. Haruna(I liked her more when she was between 18-23, but now she is very beatiful too, espcecialy with brown hair)
2. Tomomi and Mami(can't choose between them, both are very cute and lovely)
3. Rina
4.  -

– Voice
1. Haruna
2. Mami
3. Tomomi
4. Rina

– Humour
1.Tomomi
2.Mami
3.Haruna
4.Rina

– Maturity
No ideea, I didn't followed them for too long(know the band for 2 , 2.5 years but only since few months ago watched some interviews and found this forum) in order to make an ideea, but I belive  that Rina and Haruna are the most mature from them.

I have to say that I think Tomomi is prettiest. Haruna has the best voice, Mami is best instrument, and Rina is best all around in number of instruments and creativity.