Message reputation : 100% (1 vote)
A lot of good posts here and technical stuff. I have no idea for that part, lipsync or not or whatever, if they did it they must have done it for a good reason not just for the "lolz"... And it seems it was perfect because some say it's live some say it's not... In the end they had their reasons and surely didn't want to harm the fans in any way.
Anyways, her problems are past now. They should probably have protected her more during that time, not sure who wanted to perform and all but don't forget it's a business... You don't just cancel things or change whole plans like that even if they probably should have think about the long term and not just some shows.
My impression is that the staff cares about SCANDAL, the girls like their staff. But it's a business and every band has probably some problems at some point. SCANDAL had that problem and now HARU (and the band I think!!!) is stronger and healthy.
She went through a lot but that made her grow up and stronger IMO. They all worked hard but HARU probably had the hardest part in the band because she had to learn her instrument like the others but also be the main vocal (yes TIMO and MAMI sing too but a lot less it's different) and to finish she also had to be the leader for every interview and all that. In the end everything is fine, it's not like she had a trauma or something.
She may have a slightly different voice now to sing some songs differently but who cares as long as she is healthy and happy? And she certainly looks healthy and happy